Guidelines for Judging Student Competitive Papers
Issue Area_____________________________________________________________________
Author(s)______________________________________________________________________
Title__________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
Institution___________________________________________ Grand Total____________
Awards will be made for 1st and 2nd place papers of high quality research in each Issue Area for graduate and undergraduate students. The opinion of the judges is final.I. Paper Submission (75%)
_____(10) 1. Abstract
_____(10) 2. Introduction
_____(15) 3. Materials and methods
_____(20) 4. Results and Discussion 20
_____(5) 5. Conclusion
_____(5) 6. Style and presentation
_____(5) 7. Originality
_____(5) 8. Collaboration
_____(75) Paper Subtotal
II. Oral Presentation (25%)
_____(5) 1. Organization
2.
Delivery
_____(5) a. Effective use of
time
_____(5) b. Clarity and
intonation
_____(10) c. Use and quality of
visual aids
_____(25) Presentation Subtotal 25
______(100) Competitive Paper Grand Total